In an interview for Montana Public Radio, retired state supreme court Justice James C. Nelson urged more people to pay attention to the deluge of money being spent by politically conservative interests to shape the makeup of state courts, which hear and decide thousands of matters every year affecting all parts of our lives and communities.
Nelson (pictured), speaking with MTPR News Director Eric Whitney, cited studies sponsored by ACS that show effects of the flooding of money from, primarily business interests into state judicial elections – 89 percent of all state court judges face voters in some type of election. And the financial impact, driven by politics or ideology, on the judicial system is not good.
In the interview, which has aired over the last several days and runs a bit longer than 8 minutes, Nelson focused on research released in October by ACS, Skewed Justice. It showed, among other items, a disconcerting impact special interests are having on the outcome of criminal justice cases. (Nelson also noted the 2013 ACS-sponsored report, Justice at Risk as offering more evidence of the detrimental effect money is having on state supreme courts, which should be impartial.)
Nelson, citing Skewed Justice, said it revealed that the more TV ads aired during state supreme court judicial elections, the less likely justices are to vote in favor of criminal defendants. Thus, special interests or as Nelson calls them dark forces, are at least putting a thumb on the scale of justice, so-to-speak. One that only the privileged in this country has the means to do.
Listen to the interview here and read Nelson’s ACSblog post from earlier this year on the Supreme Court cases that have altered precedent, weakening a long tradition of campaign finance regulations in elections.
[picture by Eric Whitney]