by Tom Nolan, Associate Professor of Criminology, Merrimack College; 27-year veteran of the Boston Police Department
The city of Cleveland recently settled a federal wrongful death lawsuit for $6 million with the estate of Tamir Rice, a 12-year-old boy shot to death by Cleveland police officers on November 22, 2014. The shooting death of Rice, along with the deaths of Eric Garner, Sandra Bland, Freddie Gray, Michael Brown, Walter Scott and too many others have led to the incisive interrogation of the police narrative in their use of deadly force, particularly in the shooting deaths of men and women of color. Not all such deaths however, have received the widespread condemnation and exposure that the deaths of Rice, et al. saw, exposure that spawned the Black Lives Matter movement.
A journalist from the San Francisco Bay area recently sent me a video taken with a police body camera from a May evening in 2014, looking for analysis, context and commentary. The video showed police officers from the city of Hayward, California as well as officers from the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) police attempting to take James Greer, a 46-year-old man of color and grandfather who reportedly weighed 380 pounds, into custody on suspicion of driving under the influence. Hayward police had stopped Greer’s pickup truck and administered a brief field sobriety test before making the decision to arrest Mr. Greer. An officer asked Mr. Greer if he suffered from any medical conditions and he replied that he suffered from a hernia and pointed to the area of his stomach. Greer initially cooperated with officers, but then began offering resistance that can best be described as minimal and perfunctory. As is in keeping with standard police practices that are of late far too frequently captured and memorialized via video, Greer was immediately, violently, and decisively slammed to the pavement—on his stomach.
I have seen many of these “police videos” and am frequently sought out for comment and perspective on what is depicted. What I saw in the Hayward police video was one of the most shocking, outrageous, offensive, and noxious examples of police excess that I have ever witnessed—this in a career as a police practitioner, academic, observer, and analyst that dates back to the 1970s.