But that verdict was overturned by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. Even though the appeals court found Phelps' messages "utterly distasteful," it said they were protected by the First Amendment. The Fourth Circuit, as noted by the Religion Clause blog, also concluded that Phelps' Web site postings concerning the dead solider were "imaginative and hyperbolic rhetoric intended to spark debate."

"If you've got Justice Anthony Kennedy on your side, you can pretty much do what you want. Without him, you're the author of an angry dissent,"