In February, the Supreme Court of the United States stayed implementation of the Clean Power Plan, which provides the EPA with its best chance to cut future greenhouse gas emissions. On Tuesday, Sept. 27, the United State Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit will hear oral arguments in a consolidated case, known as West Virginia, et. al. v. EPA. This case will determine whether it is within the EPA’s power to regulate air quality by setting strict standards for carbon emission. ACS invited experts to explore the issues that will be presented before the Court.
by David Arkush, Director, Congress Watch, Public Citizen
We are often told that environmental concerns are akin to luxury goods that we cannot afford. Protecting the environment has a cost, the story goes and we will pay it in higher prices. Opponents of the EPA Clean Power Plan have made this type of claim, in some of its more extreme incarnations, central to their legal challenge in West Virginia v. EPA.
According to a group of local chambers of commerce and manufacturing associations, the Clean Power Plan will cause “economic disaster”—largely due to higher electricity prices—in which “thousands of businesses” will “lay off workers or close their doors entirely.” Local Bus. Br. 23–24. In the words of the 60Plus Association, a Koch-Brothers-affiliated group that purports to represent seniors, the rule will cause people on fixed and low incomes to “suffer greatly” from “grinding, day-to-day deprivations.” Id. at 12–13. I will turn back to these arguments in a moment. But first, it is worth raising something important that the challengers and their amici completely ignore: the harms of climate change.
Climate change is already damaging American consumers and businesses and it threatens massive future harm. By spurring more extreme weather events, climate change will cause trillions of dollars’ worth of damage to property and infrastructure. A 2014 analysis projects $525 billion in damage to coastal property alone, in just the next 15 years. The damage from extreme weather will, in turn, force businesses to raise prices and governments to raise taxes. Drought, floods and other weather events will raise the price of basic needs like food and water while lowering their quality. In addition to being poorer, we will be less healthy, burdened by more heat-related and food-, water- and insect-borne illnesses.